*BLOG

November 2026

Critical Next Steps for EU Policy: Strengthening Media’s Bargaining Power over Generative AI
A digital collage styled like an early twentieth century illustration. The title at the top reads “The AI-Deal.” A man in a suit with the OpenAI logo instead of a face stands on a stage and points to a board that says “ALL YOUR DATA.” In front of him, a seated woman wearing a blindfold holds a glowing smartphone. Small winged figures carry banners reading “Innovation”, “Productivity”, "Efficiency" and “Effortless” presenting commercial narratives about AI that mask the real exchange. Floating eye icons around the scene indicate surveillance.

Original text: https://medium.com/@TheDataTank/critical-next-steps-for-eu-policy-strengthening-medias-bargaining-power-over-generative-ai-1feba9b6933e

Co-authors: Anna Colom, The Data Tank | Paul Keller, Open Future | Mira Milosevic, Global Forum for Media Development (GFMD)| Marta Poblet, The Data Tank | Wout van Wijk, News Media Europe


We are at a critical juncture for media, information integrity and democracy. Major structural changes that began with social media in the 2010s are now accelerating, driven by a few powerful tech companies dominating General Purpose AI (GPAI) models. This power is compounded by extractive market and operational practices and the way Large Language Models and their AI assistants and agents unreliably but confidently regurgitate information while seeking to monopolise the attention of the audience. This, at the costs of public interest and independent media.
‍

To address these challenges, technical solutions tackling content attribution, preventing unsolicited scraping, building digital skills, and setting newsroom guidelines remain essential at the newsroom level. However, the literature is clear on the need for ‘holistic solutions that strengthen the collective and bargaining power of media’ involving ‘a multiplicity of instruments, including effective regulatory approaches and the creation of and investment in alternative public digital infrastructure’.
‍

Policy ambitions do not automatically translate into increased bargaining power, effective enforcement, or viable alternatives. Instead, targeted initiatives are needed that tackle the current power asymmetries straight on.
‍

The window for action is open but time is running out. So, drawing on the proposals shared by seven leading experts in this field during the panel discussion ‘Strengthening Media’s Bargaining Power over Generative AI: Next Steps for EU Policy’, –some also co-authors of this article– we summarise the proposed critical next steps as follows:
‍

On fair compensation and copyright: roll out regulation fit for the current age, rather than expanding inadequate policies.
‍

Firstly, where works are used to train and operate generative AI systems, the current context requires a shift from a framework built on exclusive rights to one built on remuneration. This concerns the use of works as inputs for generative AI, not copyright in general. Insisting on licensing under exclusive rights reproduces the asymmetry it is meant to fix: large AI providers choose whom to pay, and smaller and minority-language media are left out. A statutory remuneration right, attached to the commercial deployment of generative AI systems rather than only to training, would ensure that all media whose work underpins these systems share in the value they create, without depending on individual bargaining power. As long as licensing continues alongside such a remuneration right, it needs guardrails. Paul Keller, Director of Policy at Open Future, proposes prohibiting exclusive content deals between media organisations and very large platforms or gatekeepers. Exclusive deals turn content into a competitive moat: they entrench the position of the largest AI providers, shut out smaller and European developers, and leave media dependent on a single buyer.
‍

However, as reflected in the current draft of UNESCO’s guidance on fair compensation for news there is no one pathway that will work alone or everywhere and the areas of regulation cut across: (i) Rights based arrangements, (ii) Competition-based arrangements, and (iii) Fiscal or levy based arrangements.
‍

Second, there is a need for new enforcement tools. Current AI systems involve content and copyright uses such as training, retrieval, summarisation, and others that do not map into the traditional relationship between a publisher and a search or aggregation platform.
‍

Digital platforms cannot simply assume that the value created by press publishers is available to them to use for free. But, big players can at the moment choose whom to negotiate and whether to negotiate to the detriment of particularly smaller publishers.
‍

There is therefore a need for tools for enforcement, such as investigative powers and remedies that can be imposed, complemented by measures including meaningful transparency mechanisms, a shift in the burden of proof, and a scalable approach to licensing. Licensing schemes alone do not solve the fact that AI summaries now include answers so audiences move away from publishers, leading to disintermediation. The media sector needs to be more pragmatic, unite and ask for viable market alternatives and these involve not only licensing but also competition tools. Competition or media authorities can impose or intervene to restore fair competition, reduce or eliminate bottlenecks, mitigate dependencies and provide alternatives.
‍

Competition policy and digital regulation to address structural dependencies, decentralise power, and create the conditions for diverse, thriving alternative ecosystem.
‍

As stated during the event by Maria Luisa Stasi, Head of Law and Policy for Digital Markets at Article 19, in addition to a new approach to licensing, and tools for enforcement and its monitoring, there is a need for alternatives to the current technology and infrastructure themselves in order to dilute the power of and dependence on large AI corporations. This goal can be achieved by opening up the market and controlling gatekeeping power, supporting new and diverse entrants inclusive of small players and public interest technologists, acting at the level of incentives but also financial support, and using tools such as R&D and procurement. These measures need to be accompanied by an enabling ecosystem based on portability, interoperability and enhanced transparency.
‍

Content licensing marketplaces, platforms that let publishers license their work to AI companies without having to negotiate a bilateral deal with each one, are another piece of infrastructure taking shape, largely built by some of the same companies whose systems created the problem in the first place. As argued by Courtney C. Radsch, if the sector’s whole strategy is to negotiate a better position inside marketplaces owned and governed by Big Tech, we risk ending up dependent on infrastructure that cannibalises public interest media and its content. A strategy that works for media and democracy should not be relying solely on ‘their’ systems. In Europe, the direction of travel is either consolidation into larger infrastructure companies like Cloudflare, or collective licensing led by collective management organisations such as the Danish Press Publications’ Collective Management Organization (DPCMO). Few independent marketplaces are accessible to small and community media, especially those in minority languages with no strong collecting society behind them.
‍

Centering the public interest: the importance of principles and normative frameworks
‍

As argued during the event by Prof. Natali Helberger, co-Founder of the AI, Media and Democracy Lab, there is a need for a new knowledge and innovation ecosystem that serves public interest alternatives. Asking who is in the best position to develop public interest alternatives, and how these parties can be enabled and incentivised is an important first step into the right direction. Next to this we need more agreement of what genuinely public-interest oriented infrastructures mean, also from the perspective of citizens, and what values should guide their development.
‍

Underpinning these decisive regulatory measures, then, are values and principles, as argued by Saorla McCabe, Deputy Secretary to the IPDC — UNESCO: ‘It is important that any policy effort in this area is built on a common vision, shared values and normative foundations’ including ’human rights, freedom of expression, and media pluralism’. McCabe, who co-led the Development of UNESCO’s ‘Guidance on Fair Compensation for News’, also reminded us during the event that these policy efforts need to take into account that these challenges affect the very foundations of democratic societies.
‍

Horizontal empowerment and collective action
‍

Gaining bargaining power entails being bolder and owning the infrastructure itself, empowering existing collective initiatives and proceeding with creating its own marketplaces as a media sector.
‍

Organisations and newsrooms need support to join initiatives like SPUR, the publishing-industry coalition behind the Content Telemetry Standard, which shows a publisher whether their content has been crawled, cited or used to ground an AI answer. Likewise, they can consider collectives such as the common data spaces, and notably the European media data space, or follow the examples of collectives, such as Mozilla Data Collective, one of the few examples of a non-profit platform governed by its contributors, built on community-sourced data.
‍

Ultimately, enforcing regulation and addressing these power asymmetries is essential and urgent, not only to address the sustainability of the media sector and the integrity of information, but also to protect democratic resilience and the diversity of languages and high quality information providers of different kind and contexts. Policy on copyright and fair compensation needs to favour sector-wide remuneration over individually negotiated licensing under exclusive rights, which mainly benefits large players. Policies aiming at addressing the current power asymmetries and sustaining a thriving and diverse media sector need to be complemented by competition measures and enforcement, and support an alternative knowledge and infrastructure ecosystem. This ecosystem needs to be grounded in public interests principles, as well as on principles of transparency, portability and interoperability, and offer a meaningful alternative to a handful of concentrated technology players. This creates new opportunities, also for smaller players.
‍

‍